Asana Vs. Trello: Comparison & Expert Reviews For 2024

Featured Tools

1. 

   Hub Planner

   This is an aggregated rating for this tool including ratings from Crozdesk users and ratings from other sites.

   4.2

   Visit Website
2. 

   ClickUp

   This is an aggregated rating for this tool including ratings from Crozdesk users and ratings from other sites.

   4.7

   Visit Website
3. 

   Miro

   This is an aggregated rating for this tool including ratings from Crozdesk users and ratings from other sites.

   4.8

   Visit Website

Asana and Trello are often compared because they both offer simple, affordable task management for teams of all sizes. But how do you decide between them? In this article, I’ll compare and contrast both tools in depth, focusing on things like similarities, differences, key features, pricing, and best use cases. In doing so, I hope to help you make an informed decision on what is the best project management software for you, your business, and your team.

Asana Vs. Trello: Expert Summary

Asana and Trello are both popular project management tools that help teams organize tasks and collaborate effectively. They offer features like task assignments, due dates, and project tracking to enhance team productivity. Both platforms also support integrations with other tools to streamline workflows.

Asana stands out with its advanced project management features, such as timeline views and workload management, which are ideal for complex projects. It also offers more robust reporting and analytics capabilities, allowing teams to gain deeper insights into their project progress. Additionally, Asana's automation features help reduce manual work and improve efficiency.

Trello, on the other hand, excels with its simplicity and ease of use, making it a great choice for smaller teams or less complex projects. Its visual Kanban boards provide a clear and intuitive way to manage tasks and workflows. Trello's extensive library of Power-Ups allows users to customize their boards with additional features and integrations as needed.

Choosing between Asana and Trello depends on the specific needs of your team and the complexity of your projects. For more advanced project management and detailed reporting, Asana is the better choice, while Trello is ideal for simpler, more visual task management.

Need expert help selecting the right tool?

With one-on-one help, we guide you to your top software options. Narrow down your software search & make a confident choice.

Get free tool advice

Why Trust Our Software Analysis

We’ve been testing and reviewing software since 2012. As project managers ourselves, we know how critical and difficult it is to make the right decision when choosing between software. 

We invest in deep research to help our audience make better software purchasing decisions. We’ve tested more than 2,000 tools for different project management use cases and written over 1,000 comprehensive software reviews. Learn how we stay transparent & our software review methodology.

Side By Side Comparison Of Asana And Trello

Opens new window

Asana

Opens new window

Asana is ideal for teams that require robust project tracking and advanced task management features, making it perfect for larger organizations with complex workflows. Its comprehensive suite of tools supports detailed project planning and collaboration, catering to users who need a high level of organization and accountability.

Asana Pros

• User-friendly interface
• Extensive integration options
• Enhances team collaboration
• Offers a free plan for small teams

Asana Cons

• Steep learning curve for new users
• Limited task assignment (one person per task)
• Projects can become complex

Price:

From $10.99/user/month (billed annually) + free plan available

Trial:

30-day free trial

View WebsiteOpens new window

Opens new window

Trello

Opens new window

Trello is best suited for smaller teams or individuals who prefer a visual and straightforward approach to task management. Its intuitive Kanban-style boards are excellent for users who need a simple, flexible way to organize tasks and projects without the complexity of more feature-rich software.

Trello Pros

• Instantaneous real-time updates
• Effortless member addition
• Adaptive responsive design
• Efficient Kanban system

Trello Cons

• Insufficient advanced features
• Scalability concerns for larger teams
• Dependency on external integrations

Price:

From $5/user/month (billed annually) + free plan available

Trial:

14-day free trial

View WebsiteOpens new window

Asana Vs. Trello Feature Comparison

To compare Asana and Trello, I have identified 10 must-have features for any project management software. Below is a feature comparison chart that shows which of these features each tool has.

Differences Between Asana And Trello

1. Pricing Structure:

• Trello: Offers a free plan with unlimited users but limits the number of boards to 10. Paid plans start at $5 per user per month.
• Asana: Provides a free plan with unlimited projects but limits the number of users to 10. Paid plans start at $10.99 per user per month.

2. User Interface:

• Trello: Known for its simple, intuitive Kanban board interface, making it easy for users to get started quickly.
• Asana: Offers a more complex interface with multiple views (List, Board, Calendar, Timeline), which can be more challenging to navigate initially but provides greater flexibility.

3. Task Management:

• Trello: Best suited for simpler projects with similar types of tasks. It supports basic task information like members, labels, checklists, dates, attachments, and comments.
• Asana: Better for complex projects with diverse tasks. It includes advanced features like subtasks, milestones, and dependencies.

4. Team Collaboration:

• Trello: Basic collaboration features such as comments within task cards, attachments, and notifications.
• Asana: More robust collaboration tools, including built-in communication channels for direct messaging and project conversations.

5. Progress Tracking:

• Trello: Uses visual elements like checklists and stickers to track progress, making it more visually appealing and fun.
• Asana: Offers detailed reporting features and multiple views for tracking progress, including real-time project data displayed in graphs and pie charts.

6. Automation:

• Trello: Provides built-in automation with the Butler tool, allowing users to create rules, buttons, due date automations, and scheduled automations.
• Asana: Offers automation through Asana Rules, but custom and dynamic automation rules are reserved for higher-tier plans.

7. Administration and Permissions:

• Trello: In the free plan, all team members have admin status. For more granular permissions, users need to upgrade to Trello Premium.
• Asana: Admins manage everything through the Admin Console, with advanced permissions and custom roles available in paid plans.

8. Security:

• Trello: Implements TLS 1.2 with 128-bit advanced encryption and offers 2-factor authentication. It holds several certifications like SOC 2 and SOC 3, ISO, and GDPR.
• Asana: Uses Amazon’s relational database services (RDS) for data management, with data centers across Europe, Australia, and Japan. It offers multi-factor identification and Google Single Sign-On (SSO).

Similarities Between Asana And Trello

1. Core Features: Both Asana and Trello offer essential project management features such as task creation, assignment, and tracking. 

2. User-Friendliness: Both platforms are known for their user-friendly interfaces, making it easy for teams to adopt and use them effectively.

3. Multiple Views: Both tools provide multiple views for managing projects. Trello primarily uses Kanban boards but also has timelines, calendars, and tables; Asana offers List, Board, and Calendar views.

4. Integrations: Trello supports 100+ app integrations and 200+ Power-Ups, which are add-ons that enhance board functionality. Asana integrates with 200+ apps, including popular tools like Google Drive, Zoom, GitHub, and Slack.

5. Automation: Both platforms offer automation features to streamline workflows and reduce manual tasks. Trello uses Butler for automation, while Asana offers automation through Asana Rules.

6. Collaboration Tools: Both tools support team collaboration through comments, file sharing, and notifications within tasks.

7. Mobile and Desktop Apps: Asana and Trello both offer native desktop and mobile applications, ensuring users can manage their projects on the go.

8. Security Features: Both platforms prioritize security, offering features like two-factor authentication, data encryption, and compliance with industry standards such as ISO and SOC2.

9. Free Plans: Both Asana and Trello offer robust free plans that are suitable for small teams and individual users, making them accessible to a wide range of users.

10. Support Resources: Both tools provide extensive support resources, including knowledge bases, tutorials, forums, and community support to help users get the most out of the platforms.

Best Use Cases For Asana And Trello

Best Use Cases for Asana

1. Project Management: Assign and track tasks, mark milestones and deadlines, monitor workload and resources.
2. Marketing & Communications: Streamline campaign planning, content creation, and performance tracking.
3. Centralized Operations & IT: Manage IT projects, track operational tasks, and ensure smooth workflows.
4. Product & Engineering: Coordinate product development, track engineering tasks, and manage sprints.
5. Sales & Customer Success: Track sales pipelines, manage customer relationships, and streamline follow-ups.
6. Design Teams: Organize design projects, manage creative requests, and collaborate on design tasks.
7. CRM: Customize CRM to help sales teams manage leads and accounts effectively. 
8. Education: Plan curriculum, manage student projects, and coordinate educational events.
9. Event Management: Plan and execute events, track tasks, and manage event logistics.
10. Business Owners: Oversee business operations, manage projects, and track team performance.

Best Use Cases for Trello

1. Project Management: Assign and track tasks, mark milestones and deadlines, monitor workload and resources.
2. Brainstorming: Unleash creativity and keep ideas visible, collaborative, and actionable.
3. Nonprofits: Coordinate volunteer activities, manage fundraising campaigns, and track program progress.
4. Editorial Calendar: Use Trello as a command center for content curation, revisions, and publishing.
5. Finance: Streamline finance operations for more transparency and fewer missed deadlines.
6. Client Billing: Manage clients, time-tracking, appointments, and more in one system. 
7. Information Technology (IT): Set up queues and projects your way for efficient IT management.
8. Meetings: Make team meetings more productive, empowering, and engaging.
9. Process Tracking: View progress at a glance and quickly identify blockers in any process.
10. Professional Services: Juggle multiple clients and priorities with ease using automation and advanced views.

Asana Vs. Trello Pricing Comparison

This side-by-side price comparison shows Asana’s price compared to Trello.

Asana vs. Trello Pricing Comparison

This side-by-side price comparison shows Asana’s price compared to Trello.

Asana Pricing

Trello Pricing

Asana vs Trello Pricing Summary

In comparing the pricing plans of Asana and Trello, Trello generally offers lower-cost options, especially for smaller teams or individuals. Trello's Standard plan starts at $5 per user per month, which is significantly cheaper than Asana's Starter plan at $10.99 per user per month. However, Asana provides more advanced features and customization options at higher pricing tiers, which may offer more value for larger teams or enterprises with complex project management needs. Ultimately, the choice between Asana and Trello will depend on the specific requirements and budget of the user or organization.

How We Review & Compare Software

Comparing project management software requires a detailed analysis of each one’s functionality and how well they meet specific use cases. My approach is rooted in extensive personal experience, having tried and researched numerous project management software. Here’s how I evaluate these solutions to compare them fairly and accurately.

Core Functionality - 25% of total weighting score

• Task Management: Create, assign, and track tasks.
• Collaboration Tools: Facilitate team communication and file sharing.
• Scheduling: Manage timelines and deadlines.
• Reporting: Generate progress and performance reports.
• Integration: Connect with other tools and software.

Additional Standout Features - 25% of total weighting score

• Research competitive feature benchmarking.
• Survey user reviews for standout offerings.
• Test software for unique or niche functionality.

Usability - 10% of total weighting score

• Intuitive interface design.
• Balance between power and ease of use.
• Minimal learning curve for new users.

Onboarding - 10% of total weighting score

• Availability of training videos and templates.
• Interactive product tours and chatbots.
• Webinars and other educational resources.
• Ease of migration and quick start to realizing value.

Customer Support - 10% of total weighting score

• Availability of 24/7 support.
• Multiple support channels (chat, email, phone).
• Quality and responsiveness of support team.

Value For Money - 10% of total weighting score

• Competitive pricing.
• Features offered relative to cost.
• Availability of different pricing tiers and plans.

Customer Reviews - 10% of total weighting score

• Overall customer satisfaction.
• Commonly reported strengths and weaknesses.
• Frequency and nature of updates and improvements.

Understanding Our Scoring

We rate our reviews on a scale of one to five stars. The more stars a software scores in any given criteria, the better its performance is going to be. The scores are absolute, rather than relative to other software in the category.

• ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ - An exceptional score, it doesn’t get better than this
• ⭐⭐⭐⭐ - A very good score, while some room for improvement
• ⭐⭐⭐ - A fair score, potential issues reported but still functional
• ⭐⭐ - A poor score, there are significant issues reported
• ⭐ - A failing score, they are missing something or it is broken
  

Asana And Trello Alternatives

Here are some additional project management alternatives to Asana and Trello. 

• Best Asana alternatives
• Best Trello alternatives

What Next?

Want to connect with other digital project managers to share resources and best practices? Join our membership community and get access to 100+ templates, samples, and examples and connect with 100s of other digital project managers in Slack.