Smartsheet vs. Basecamp: Comparison & Expert Reviews For 2025
Smartsheet offers a versatile, web-based platform to manage your projects with flexibility and precision. Designed to resemble a familiar spreadsheet interface, Smartsheet combines the simplicity of traditional spreadsheets with powerful project management features, including resource management notifications, Gantt charts, automation features, and support for agile methodologies.
Basecamp provides a straightforward and user-friendly project management tool for team collaboration. Emphasizing simplicity, Basecamp integrates essential tools like to-do lists, message boards, file sharing, scheduling, and real-time chat into a single platform. Its unique features help teams stay organized without the complexity of traditional project management software.
While Smartsheet excels in detailed project tracking and automation, Basecamp shines for its simplicity and ease of use, making them different yet valuable tools for various team needs.
In this article, you’ll find a comprehensive comparison of their features, pros and cons, pricing, and more, to help you decide which project management software is right for your team.
Smartsheet vs. Basecamp: An Overview
Smartsheet
Basecamp
Why You Can Trust Us
Smartsheet vs. Basecamp Pricing Comparison
| Smartsheet | Basecamp | |
|---|---|---|
| Free Trial | 30-day free trial | 30-day free trial |
| Pricing | From $9/user/month (billed annually) | From $15/user/month |
Get free help from our project management software advisors to find your match.
Get Expert AdviceOpens new windowSmartsheet vs. Basecamp Pricing & Hidden Costs
Smartsheet pricing is structured around tiered subscriptions, with costs generally increasing based on the number of users and access to advanced features. While Smartsheet offers a flexible range of functionalities suited for various team sizes, businesses may need to upgrade their plan to access some enterprise-grade tools or automation capabilities.
Basecamp pricing offers a flat-rate pricing model that provides all users with access to its complete set of features for a single monthly fee. This approach can offer predictability in budgeting and may be more cost-effective for larger teams that need to accommodate unlimited users.
To choose the right tool for your needs, evaluate the core features you require and anticipate future growth. This ensures the pricing model you select aligns with your long-term budget and project demands.
Smartsheet vs. Basecamp Feature Comparison
Smartsheet’s document management capabilities allow users to attach files directly to rows, tasks, comments, and other project elements. This feature supports centralized access to project-related documents, which makes it particularly valuable for complex projects that require detailed document tracking and version control.
Basecamp features intuitive to-do lists that simplify task management and foster clear team communication. These lists allow users to assign responsibilities, set due dates, and monitor progress, which makes them especially effective for small teams aiming to stay organized and accountable.
Both platforms offer basic key features such as collaboration tools, a mobile app, and features to assign tasks. While Smartsheet excels in managing intricate project details with its grid-based dashboard structure and automation options, Basecamp stands out for promoting straightforward collaboration and accessible task oversight through its clean and user-friendly interface.
| Smartsheet | Basecamp | |
|---|---|---|
| API | ||
| Budgeting | ||
| Calendar Management | ||
| Contact Management | ||
| Dashboards | ||
| Dependency Tracking | ||
| Document Sharing | ||
| Expense Tracking | ||
| External Integrations | ||
| File Sharing | ||
| Gantt Charts | ||
| Kanban Boards | ||
| Project Management | ||
| Resource Management | ||
| Task Scheduling/Tracking | ||
| Time Management | ||
| Workflow Management |
Get free help from our project management software advisors to find your match.
Get Expert AdviceOpens new windowSmartsheet vs. Basecamp Integrations
| Integration | Smartsheet | Basecamp |
|---|---|---|
| Microsoft Teams | ✅ | ✅ |
| Slack | ✅ | ✅ |
| Salesforce | ✅ | ❌ |
| Google Drive | ✅ | ❌ |
| Jira | ✅ | ✅ |
| Trello | ❌ | ✅ |
| Dropbox | ✅ | ✅ |
| HubSpot | ✅ | ✅ |
| API | ✅ | ✅ |
| Zapier | ✅ | ✅ |
With Smartsheet’s Salesforce integration, you can auto-sync project updates with your sales pipeline to keep launch tasks moving fast after a deal closes. It’s especially useful when you need to kick off onboarding or delivery work the moment a contract is signed.
Basecamp’s Slack integration is great for keeping quick team chats tied to your project threads without switching apps. It helps keep informal updates and decisions visible to the whole team without cluttering project files.
Both help in their own ways—Smartsheet gets your sales and project teams aligned, while Basecamp keeps day-to-day collaboration simple and connected.
Smartsheet vs. Basecamp Security, Compliance & Reliability
| Factor | Smartsheet | Basecamp |
|---|---|---|
| Data Encryption | Smartsheet encrypts data at rest and in transit using AES-256 encryption. | Basecamp uses SSL/TLS encryption for data in transit. |
| Regulatory Compliance | Smartsheet complies with SOC 2 Type II and ISO/IEC 27001 standards. | Basecamp follows GDPR and CCPA compliance regulations. |
| Access Controls | Smartsheet offers role-based access controls to manage user permissions. | Basecamp provides simple user permissions and admin controls. |
| Data Backup | Smartsheet performs regular automated backups to ensure data reliability. | Basecamp conducts daily backups to secure user data. |
Smartsheet provides more comprehensive security and compliance features compared to Basecamp. To evaluate these aspects, prioritize reviewing the specific compliance certifications and encryption methods each tool offers, and consider how they align with your organization's security requirements.
Smartsheet vs. Basecamp Ease of Use
| Factor | Smartsheet | Basecamp |
|---|---|---|
| User Interface | Smartsheet offers a grid-like interface similar to spreadsheets, which can be familiar to Excel users, but complex for new users. | Basecamp features a clean, straightforward interface for quick navigation. |
| Onboarding Experience | Smartsheet provides detailed tutorials and guides for a thorough onboarding process. | Basecamp offers a simple and intuitive onboarding with minimal steps. |
| Setup | Smartsheet's setup can be time-consuming due to its customizable options. | Basecamp allows for quick setup with its predefined project templates. |
| Support | Smartsheet provides extensive customer support options, including live chat and webinars. | Basecamp offers email support and a comprehensive help center. |
Smartsheet's extensive features can be challenging to master, but its detailed support helps ease the learning curve. Basecamp is easier to start with due to its simple interface, but it might lack the depth necessary for complex projects.
Smartsheet vs Basecamp: Pros & Cons
Smartsheet
- Gives your team a lot of flexibility with how you set up sheets, dashboards, and workflows
- Proofing and approval tools can help you better collaborate with your team
- Handles complex projects and cross-team coordination better than most tools
- It takes time to set up and isn’t very intuitive for new users
- Interactive spreadsheets don’t automatically sync changes
- You can’t easily build simple task lists without doing extra setup
Basecamp
- With automatic check-ins, you can keep everyone updated without lengthy meetings.
- Basecamp's message board keeps your team communication clear and organized.
- You can easily get your team onboard with its intuitive interface.
- Basecamp's simplicity might not meet the needs of complex project workflows.
- You might find the lack of advanced reporting tools limiting.
- The tool is missing a built-in time tracking feature for tasks.
Best Use Cases for Smartsheet and Basecamp
Smartsheet
- Marketing Teams You can manage campaign timelines, creative approvals, and content calendars in one place using built-in forms, reminders, and dashboards.
- Construction Projects Smartsheet is great for tracking tasks, permits, and inspections across vendors and crews using Gantt charts and status columns.
- PMO Departments You get a clear portfolio view of all your projects, timelines, and risks with built-in reports and resource views.
- Healthcare Operations Smartsheet helps you track compliance tasks, training, and onboarding with audit-ready logs and approval workflows.
- IT Teams Smartsheet is useful for managing system rollouts, support requests, and change logs with forms, automations, and sheet linking.
- Mid-Sized Companies You get just enough structure to scale your operations without needing a full custom solution or enterprise buildout.
Basecamp
- Small businesses You'll benefit from Basecamp's straightforward design and ease of use, which are ideal for managing projects without the complexity of more robust software.
- Creative agencies Its visual communication tools and message boards support creative brainstorming and project discussions.
- Remote teams Basecamp's centralized platform keeps remote team members connected and aligned on tasks and goals.
- Startups Quick onboarding and straightforward features help startups get organized fast without a learning curve.
- Non-profits Basecamp allows non-profit teams to focus on their mission by simplifying project tracking and communication.
- Freelancers Freelancers can manage their client projects efficiently with Basecamp’s task management and client communication tools.
Get free help from our project management software advisors to find your match.
Get Expert AdviceOpens new windowWho Should Use Smartsheet, and Who Should Use Basecamp?
I believe Smartsheet is best suited for teams that need detailed project tracking and work within industries like construction or IT, where complex data management is essential. Its ability to handle dependencies, custom workflows, and strong reporting makes it especially valuable for teams managing multiple layers of information.
From my perspective, Basecamp is ideal for small businesses, startups, or creative agencies that prioritize straightforward collaboration and simplicity in their workflows. Its minimalist interface and communication-focused features help teams stay aligned without getting bogged down in overly technical setups.
In my opinion, if your team values comprehensive features and you're ready to invest time in setup, go with Smartsheet. But if you want a tool that's easy to use right out of the box, Basecamp is the way to go.
Differences Between Smartsheet and Basecamp
| Smartsheet | Basecamp | |
|---|---|---|
| Automation | Smartsheet includes advanced automation tools for workflow customization. | Basecamp lacks complex automation, focusing on simplicity instead. |
| Collaboration | Smartsheet supports detailed collaboration through document management. | Basecamp excels in team communication with its intuitive to-do lists. |
| Pricing | Smartsheet offers tiered subscriptions with additional costs for extra features. | Basecamp provides a flat-rate pricing model without hidden fees. |
| Setup Complexity | Smartsheet requires more setup time due to its customizable options. | Basecamp allows for quick setup with its predefined templates. |
| User Interface | Smartsheet's interface resembles a spreadsheet, which can be overwhelming for some. | Basecamp features a clean, simple interface that's easy to navigate. |
| Visit SmartsheetOpens new window | Visit BasecampOpens new window |
Similarities Between Smartsheet and Basecamp
| Cloud-Based Access | Smartsheet and Basecamp are both cloud-based, which allows team members to access projects from anywhere with an internet connection. |
|---|---|
| Collaboration | Both facilitate team collaboration: Smartsheet through detailed document handling and Basecamp with its focus on communication. |
| Integrations | Both tools support integrations with popular apps, like Google Workspace and Slack, to enhance functionality and collaboration. |
| Task Management | Both Smartsheet and Basecamp allow you to create and manage tasks, with Smartsheet offering detailed tracking and Basecamp providing simple to-do lists. |
| User Support | Both offer support through help centers and tutorials, with Smartsheet providing live chat and Basecamp offering email support. |
| Visit SmartsheetOpens new window Visit BasecampOpens new window | |
Join For More Project Management Insights
Want to learn more about project management and project management software? Join our membership community to access 100+ templates, samples, and examples, and connect with 100s of other digital project managers in Slack.