Skip to main content
Key Takeaways

Writing an RFP helps you clearly outline your needs: It makes it easier to compare vendors and find the best fit for your team.

RFPs are best for larger orgs: If your organization is small or your needs are simple, you might skip an RFP and instead directly contact a few vendors for quotes.

A well-crafted RFP can lead to better pricing: It can also help make sure the software meets your specific requirements and save you headaches later.

A project management software RFP, or request for proposal, is a document that lays out your requirements, budget, and evaluation criteria and asks vendors to bid against them.

Since every vendor responds to the same brief, you can compare project management software options side by side instead of piecing together sales calls and marketing pages. Done well, it lowers the risk of committing to a tool that doesn’t fit how your team works.

What to Include in a Project Management Software RFP

Most project management software RFPs follow the same basic structure. Including each of these eight sections gives vendors what they need to send you a complete, comparable proposal.

Continue Reading for Free

Create a free account to finish this article, plus get ongoing access to timely insights and practical resources.

SectionWhat it coversWhat most RFPs miss
Executive SummaryWho you are, what you need, and why nowYour decision timeline and who makes the final call
Scope of WorkThe software and services you expectData migration from your current tool
Technical RequirementsFeatures, integrations, and platformsAsking how a feature works, not whether it exists
Vendor Qualifications & ComplianceExperience, certifications, and security standardsAsking for the actual audit report, not a compliance claim
Implementation & TrainingRollout plan, timelines, and supportWho does the work: the vendor, a partner, or your team
Pricing & LicensingCosts, tiers, and licensing modelRenewal price increases and features locked to higher tiers
Contract TermsPayment, SLAs, and legal termsHow you get your data out if you leave
Submission InstructionsDeadlines, format, and contactsA shared Q&A process so every vendor gets the same answers

1. Executive Summary

Give a brief overview of the type of project management software you need, the problem you’re solving, and the outcomes you expect. Include your team size, what you’re replacing, and when you plan to decide.

What most teams miss: Vendors read this section to decide whether your deal is worth a serious response. A clear trigger (“our current tool can’t support portfolio reporting across 12 teams”) and a firm decision date signal a real buyer, and you’ll get proposals from senior sales and solutions staff instead of templated replies.

2. Scope of Work

Spell out what you expect from the vendor beyond the software itself: setup, configuration, data migration, training, and ongoing support. Include your current user count and where you expect it to be in two to three years.

What most teams miss: Migration is where timelines slip. Say which tool you’re moving from, roughly how many projects and how much historical data you need to bring over, and whether attachments and comments need to come with it. Vendors quote very differently for “import active projects” versus “migrate five years of history.”

3. Technical Requirements

List the features, integrations, and platform support you need, and label each one as a must-have, a should-have, or a nice-to-have.

What most teams miss: Yes/no requirements get a “yes” from every vendor. Instead of “Does it support resource management?”, ask vendors to explain how it handles a specific scenario, like rebalancing a designer’s workload across three overlapping projects. For integrations, ask whether each one is native, built through a third-party connector, or only on the roadmap. Those three answers mean very different things in practice.

4. Vendor Qualifications & Compliance

Specify the experience, industry certifications, and track record you expect, along with your security and compliance requirements, such as data protection standards and any regulations your industry must follow.

What most teams miss: “SOC 2 compliant” on a sales page isn’t evidence. Ask for the most recent SOC 2 Type II report (usually shared under NDA), where your data will be stored, and which subprocessors handle it. If your IT team already has a standard security questionnaire, attach it now rather than running it as a separate round after you’ve picked a favorite. Also ask for references from customers of a similar size and industry, not just the vendor’s happiest logos.

5. Implementation & Training Expectations

Describe your target rollout timeline, how you’ll measure a successful launch, and the training you need for both admins and end users.

What most teams miss: Ask who will actually do the implementation: the vendor’s own team, a certified partner, or your staff using self-serve guides. Ask for named roles, an estimated number of hours from your team, and how long dedicated support lasts after go-live. Adoption, not setup, is where most rollouts fail, so ask what the vendor does to drive usage in the first 90 days.

6. Pricing & Licensing

Ask for a full cost breakdown, including license fees, implementation, training, premium support, and add-ons. Provide your user count and growth estimate so every vendor quotes against the same numbers.

What most teams miss: The first-year price is rarely the one that hurts. Ask for a three-year total cost of ownership, any cap on renewal price increases, and minimum seat commitments. Check which features from your requirements list sit behind higher tiers, since SSO, advanced permissions, and portfolio reporting are often enterprise-only. Also ask how guest, viewer, and client seats are billed if people outside your team need access.

7. Contract Terms

Outline the terms you expect, including payment schedule, service level agreements (SLAs), warranties, and liability.

What most teams miss: Two clauses matter most once you’ve signed. First, data portability: how you export your data if you leave, in what format, and how long the vendor keeps it after termination. Second, auto-renewal: the notice period you need to cancel or renegotiate. Sharing your non-negotiable terms in the RFP means legal redlines happen before you’ve chosen a vendor, not after, when you have less leverage.

Get timely perspective on the shifts, decisions, and trade-offs shaping your role, plus practical resources you can put to work.

Get timely perspective on the shifts, decisions, and trade-offs shaping your role, plus practical resources you can put to work.

8. Submission Instructions

Give vendors a deadline, a single point of contact, and the format you want responses in. Spell out the details, like file types and delivery method, when you issue the RFP.

Hermann Fink

What most teams miss

Set a deadline for vendor questions and share all answers with every vendor, without naming who asked. It keeps the process fair and stops one vendor from gaining an edge through side conversations. If you can, give vendors a response template that mirrors your scoring matrix, so evaluation becomes a matter of filling in scores, not hunting through 40-page PDFs.

Assemble Your PM Software RFP Team

Filling in those eight sections well takes input from people across the business. Bringing them in early means fewer gaps in your requirements and less rework later. Here’s who to include.

Project Sponsor

The project sponsor provides strategic direction and makes sure the RFP aligns with your broader business goals. They help prioritize requirements, secure resources for the selection process, and approve the final RFP. This role is typically filled by a senior manager or executive who champions the project.

Functional Experts

Functional or subject matter experts know the technical requirements the software has to meet, so their input shapes the features and integrations you ask for. Look to department heads or senior team members in IT, operations, or project management.

Procurement or RFP Writers

Procurement professionals or RFP writers make sure the document is structured correctly, follows any necessary legal project management or organizational guidelines, and uses language vendors can easily understand. This role is usually filled by someone in procurement or a dedicated RFP writer.

End Users and Stakeholders

End users and stakeholders know the day-to-day challenges the software needs to solve, which helps you identify must-have features and potential roadblocks early. Consider involving team leads, project managers, and regular users from different departments.

Define Must-Haves & Goals

With your team in place, agree on what the new tool must do, and why, before you start writing. These answers become the substance of your scope of work, technical requirements, and compliance sections, and give vendors what they need to respond accurately.

Consider the following:

  • Pain points with the current system: What’s frustrating your team right now? Identify specific issues, like slow task tracking or a lack of real-time updates.
  • Required improvements and success outcomes: What does success look like for your team? Define key improvements, such as better collaboration or less manual work, and set measurable outcomes to track progress.
  • Functional, technical, and compliance needs: Does the software need to integrate with existing tools or meet industry standards? List essentials like API access or compliance with data regulations.
  • User roles, usage levels, and workflows: Who will use the software, and how often? Consider how it needs to support different roles, from project managers to individual contributors.
  • Deployment preferences: Do you need a cloud-based or on-premise solution? Base the decision on your data security needs and IT infrastructure.

Define Your Evaluation Criteria

Clearly defined evaluation criteria help you make an informed decision that is objective, transparent, and aligned with your business goals. Establishing these criteria before reviewing proposals helps you avoid bias and maintain focus on what matters most to your team. Here's how to define your evaluation criteria.

What Matters Most?

Choose 3–5 weighted categories that align with your goals and priorities. This helps focus your evaluation on what's truly important, and effectively weigh the pros and cons of project management software providers. Common RFP scoring categories for project management software include:

  • Functionality
  • User experience
  • Cost
  • Vendor reputation
  • Scalability

Identify which categories best reflect your needs, and assign them weights based on their importance to your project.

Use a Scoring Matrix

A scoring matrix helps quantify your evaluation process and make it more objective. Assign weights to each category based on your internal priorities. For example, if functionality is key, it might carry a weight of 40%, while cost is 20%. Score each criterion on a 1–5 or 1–10 scale to differentiate vendor proposals. Adjust weightings to reflect what matters most to your team.

Clarify Your Scoring Process

Define who will score the proposals and how they’ll maintain consistency. Use a standardized rubric to guide reviewers and schedule a meeting to align everyone on the scoring process before you begin. This helps all reviewers understand the criteria and approach so they can conduct fair and balanced evaluations. Make sure each reviewer knows their role and how to apply the scoring system.

Issue the Project Management Software RFP

Issuing the RFP isn’t just about sending it out—it’s about giving vendors the right access, timelines, and instructions so they can respond effectively. A smooth distribution process sets the tone for the quality of proposals you’ll get back. Here’s how to issue your RFP effectively.

Choose the Right Distribution Method

Consider using email, RFP software platforms, or procurement portals to distribute your RFP. A centralized system like an RFP platform helps you track responses and manage communications. If using email, consider a role-based inbox to keep all vendor interactions organized. Include a vendor contact list to get everyone the information they need.

Set Clear Timeline Expectations

A well-defined timeline makes sure vendors know what to expect and when. Include the following in your RFP:

  • RFP release date
  • Vendor Q&A window
  • Final submission deadline
  • Evaluation and selection period

Share this timeline in the RFP itself to keep everyone aligned and on track.

Define Submission Requirements

Make sure vendors know exactly how to submit their proposals. Specify accepted file formats like PDF, Microsoft Word, or Excel templates. Indicate your preferred delivery method, such as an upload portal or a reply-to inbox. Clarify whether vendors must use specific templates or forms and whether late submissions will be accepted. This clarity avoids confusion and makes sure you receive complete proposals on time.

Evaluate & Shortlist Vendor Responses

This is where your structured approach pays off, as your procurement team turns vendor RFP responses into a confident shortlist. Consistency, objectivity, and collaboration across everyone involved in the evaluation are essential. Here’s how to evaluate and shortlist vendors effectively.

  • Scheduling demos and interviews: Arrange for demos and interviews with top vendors to see their solutions in action. This gives your team a chance to ask questions and get a feel for the software's usability.
  • Checking references: Reach out to vendor-provided references to learn about their experiences. Ask about implementation challenges and support quality to gauge what you might expect.
  • Clarifying anything unclear in proposals: Don’t hesitate to contact vendors for clarification on any unclear points. It’s better to ask now than to make assumptions that could lead to issues later.

Select & Notify Vendors

Once your team has chosen a vendor, the final steps are just as important as the evaluation process. Clear, professional communication with all vendors—both selected and unselected—is crucial, as is getting internal alignment before moving into contract execution. Here are the key steps to take.

Notify Selected and Unselected Vendors

Timely, respectful communication with vendors reflects well on your organization. Send a short thank-you note or provide high-level feedback to unselected vendors to maintain good relationships for future opportunities. For the selected vendor, express enthusiasm and outline the next steps to keep momentum.

Prepare for Final Negotiations

Common negotiation items include pricing, SLAs, and contract terms. Define your team’s walk-away points in advance to avoid surprises. Use a checklist or agenda during discussions to stay focused and cover all necessary points. This preparation helps you negotiate effectively and reach a fair agreement.

Ensure Internal Alignment Before Signing

Before signing, make sure all necessary approvals are in place. This typically includes leadership or finance signoff and a legal or procurement review. Summarize the key decision drivers so internal reviewers can move quickly. Clear communication with your team prevents delays and makes sure everyone is on board with the decision.

RFP Checklist: Common Mistakes to Avoid

Before you send your RFP, run through this list. Each item covers a gap that leads to generic proposals, poor-fit vendors, or a slower project management software selection process.

  • Give vendors enough context. Include your goals, team size, current tool, and why you’re switching. Without it, you’ll get generic responses that don’t address your actual challenges.
  • State a budget range. Vendors either overshoot or skip RFPs with no budget. If you’re not sure what’s realistic, check how much project management software costs before you set your range.
  • Write specific requirements in plain language. Name the project management software features you need, rank them by priority, and keep legal language for the contract section.
  • Share your evaluation criteria. Tell vendors what you’ll score them on, such as functionality, scalability, or support, so they can address each point directly.

Do You Actually Need an RFP?

If your team is dealing with complex requirements or you're part of a regulated industry, an RFP is essential. It helps make sure you find a vendor that aligns with your specific needs and complies with industry standards. Creating an RFP is also crucial when you're managing a large budget or need multiple stakeholders on board. 

Here are some scenarios where an RFP is necessary:

  • Large-scale enterprise projects
  • Highly regulated industries
  • Complex integration requirements
  • Multiple stakeholders involved
  • Significant budget allocation

When an RFP Might Be Overkill

If your needs are straightforward or you're a small team, an RFP might be more trouble than it's worth. In such cases, you can save time by directly exploring options from a curated list of the best project management software:

Top Project Management Software To Consider

Here’s my list of the top 10 project management software options available, to help you get started in your search:

Clicks on the links below may earn a commission, which supports our independent testing and review of software and services. Learn more about how we stay transparent.

RFI vs RFP vs RFQ: What’s the Difference?

An RFI is for gathering general information, an RFP is for seeking detailed proposals, and an RFQ is for requesting pricing. Picking the right one saves time and reduces friction in your procurement process:

Document TypePurposeWhen to UseWhat to IncludeLevel of Detail Required
Request for Information (RFI)Gather general information about potential vendorsWhen exploring options and capabilities of project management softwareVendor capabilities, market trends, basic featuresLow
Request for Proposal (RFP)Solicit detailed proposals from vendorsWhen you need detailed solutions and pricing for complex needsProject requirements, evaluation criteria, vendor qualificationsHigh
Request for Quotation (RFQ)Obtain exact pricing for specific featuresWhen you have clear requirements and just need quotesSpecific features list, pricing structure, delivery termsMedium

Before You Send Your RFP

An RFP only works as well as the requirements and budget behind it. If your team is still debating what it actually needs and you need a realistic number to put in your budget section, see our breakdown of how much project management software costs. That way, you get proposals you can actually afford.

Hermann Fink

Hermann Fink is a technology enthusiast and the co-founder of Rünna Advertising, a multinational digital agency that has been active for over a decade and served clients like Ford, AstraZeneca, Disney, and Didi. In addition to being a business owner, Hermann gathered corporate experience in project management during his time at Hewlett Packard in the mid-2010s.

Interested in being reviewed? Find out more here.